BY Level
How writing is scored

BY Writing Rubric

Each piece of writing is placed on one of six steps in three parts. The steps are the same for every grade, so a child can show writing above (or below) their grade. The average step gives the Writing level.

Scored by AI (Jev, from TypeSafe) using the BY Writing Rubric, with feedback written by AI (Claude, from Anthropic). AI can make mistakes. Ask us and a BY teacher will review the score and can change it. This rubric is new and our writing teachers are still reviewing it.

StepIdeas and developmentOrganizationSentences and conventions
1. Beginning
usually Levels PreK to K
A word, a label or one idea; it may not connect to the prompt.No clear order; a single sentence or a list of ideas.Few complete sentences; capitals and spelling often missing, so meaning is hard to follow.
2. Early
usually Levels G1 to G2
A simple point about the topic with one plain detail.Some order; ideas follow one another with simple joining words (and, then).Simple complete sentences; frequent errors in capitals, end marks or spelling, but the meaning is clear.
3. Developing
usually Levels G3 to G4
A clear opinion or main idea with two reasons or details, mostly general.A beginning, a middle and an end; simple transitions (first, second, because).Mostly correct simple and compound sentences; some errors that do not block meaning; everyday words.
4. Proficient
usually Levels G5 to L8 (G6)
A clear point developed with specific reasons and examples that fit; little repetition.An introduction and a conclusion; ideas in a logical order with varied transitions.Varied sentences, including complex ones; few errors; some precise word choice.
5. Advanced
usually Level L9 (G7–8)
A precise claim supported by relevant evidence that is explained; may answer another view.A purposeful structure where each part builds the point; smooth transitions between ideas.Controlled, varied sentences; precise and academic vocabulary; errors are rare.
6. Mature
usually Level L10 (G9+)
An insightful, nuanced position; well-chosen evidence whose significance is explained; counterarguments handled.A sophisticated structure controlled for effect; transitions show how complex ideas relate.Fluent, polished sentences with a deliberate style; sophisticated vocabulary; almost no errors.